As many of you know, I'm a pretty big fan of HBO's hit show "Big Love". For those who've never seen it, it's about a polygamist family living in modern day Salt Lake City. The characters are all kind of caught between two worlds, and live in a permanent state of non-acceptance; they've been isolated from their family who still lives on the compound because of their more modern ways, and shunned by the Salt Lake City Mormon church--which no longer condones polygamy. They're also forced to hide their non-traditional family from neighbours and co-workers, both out of fear of being outed and losing their social status, and out of fear of being arrested.
The newest season of the show features the lead character deciding his life's calling is to become a Senator, despite the fact that he has these many deep, dark secrets and is living a double life that is likely to anger and upset many when exposed. He's both arrogant and idealistic, and thinks his plan to get himself elected as a conservative family man and then reveal the truth about his family is a good way to expose the prejudice and bigotry against them for what it is.
It got me thinking about our society, and how we're all just addicted to "scandal", which is really a polite way of saying we all love to judge other people. The whole world tunes into 20/20 and Dateline to watch the latest disgraced politician or fallen athlete try vainly to apologise and redeem himself. Shows like Entertainment Tonight and TMZ are huge; we all want to hear the sordid details of the lives of people who are clearly crazier than ourselves. Reality TV, "talk" shows, the 2 million incarnations of Judge Judy-type dramas; our entertainment so often revolves around the judgments we pass on other people.
What would life be like if we just lived in a world where dirty little secrets weren't so dirty? What if politicians and athletes and other public figures were not only encouraged, but embraced, by not the perception of living a "dirty little secret"-free life (which, let's face it, is an elaborate lie for almost all of us) but by their straightforwardness and honesty? What if nobody really cared what drugs Mrs. Smith had in her secret stash, or that Mr. Jones cheated on his wife, or that the head of the PTA had a criminal record? What if nobody was shocked, or entertained, or even interested in learning that other people, even famous, wealthy, accomplished people, had skeletons in their closets fairly similar to the ones most of us have?
Sure, everyone has different secrets, but almost all of us have them. Wouldn't it be a different kind of world if we were not so routinely fascinated by the secrets of others, by judging a person based upon one action or set of choices in his life? (really? Does Tiger Woods suddenly suck at golf because he likes to sleep with white girls he's not married to? If not, why do we care? His job is to be good at golf.) What if we all were forced to become more open about ourselves, and consequently, more accepting of others?
Well, there'd be a lot less TV, and people who made their livings from merely being as scandalous as possible, or "asking the tough questions" to try to unearth scandal from other people's lives...perhaps destroying them in the process, but certainly gaining a lot of media attention...would have to find new jobs. People would get their news from other sources besides the National Enquirer and Perez Hilton, and political pundits would actually have to use their power of snarkiness to deal with the issues. We'd all have to save our shock and outrage and "Oh, my God, that person is such a bad person" for things that might really deserve it. Just turn on the 5 o'clock news and see how many rapes, murders, kidnappings, and the like are going on in your neighborhood, and see if you still maintain that John Edwards is the worst guy on the face of the planet. Trust me, he's not.
On top of that, we might start being real about ourselves, and seeing that most of the secrets we keep aren't worth all the effort we go to in order to keep them. Why? To avoid public shame, or personal humiliation, or to avoid judgment by a group of people who almost all have secrets as shocking as yours? We might decide it's not worth putting someone down or ostracizing them because we've learned they like to have a drink at 3 PM, have a shoplifting habit, cheat on their spouse, dress in trashy lingerie, grow pot in their closet, or have a secret webcam site on the Internet.
I personally don't care if Bill Clinton inhaled, if Hillary is a lesbian, if Tiger can't keep it in his pants, if half of baseball's Hall Of Fame was on steroids, if my local politician likes to pick up strangers in airport bathrooms or S & M clubs, if Angelina is a crazy homewrecker, if Britney is bipolar, or if half of the contestants on my favourite reality show have rap sheets and naked photos out there. I don't care because I don't know these people, and also because I think there are better ways to make judgments on others than looking at how much "scandal" lurks in their lives. I'm not saying I'm perfectly open-minded, that I never judge, but in the grand scheme of things...who really gives a crap?
The world just might be a better place if we all realised how much energy we put into condemning other people, and how that could be re-directed and used positively.
I'd vote for a guy with three wives. I wouldn't vote for the guy who was told to be so ashamed of his three wives that he had to put so much time and energy into hiding and denying some of the most important and meaningful aspects of his life. But, that's on our society. Society tells us it's OK to tolerate just about anything shocking or taboo or unconventional, as long as it's kept sufficiently hidden. Our society encourages us all to value the outward appearance kept up by the second guy, and not the candour of the first...and when the second guy's secrets are unearthed, he's often crucified by the media, and by the public.
When did our priorities get so amazingly screwed up?
The newest season of the show features the lead character deciding his life's calling is to become a Senator, despite the fact that he has these many deep, dark secrets and is living a double life that is likely to anger and upset many when exposed. He's both arrogant and idealistic, and thinks his plan to get himself elected as a conservative family man and then reveal the truth about his family is a good way to expose the prejudice and bigotry against them for what it is.
It got me thinking about our society, and how we're all just addicted to "scandal", which is really a polite way of saying we all love to judge other people. The whole world tunes into 20/20 and Dateline to watch the latest disgraced politician or fallen athlete try vainly to apologise and redeem himself. Shows like Entertainment Tonight and TMZ are huge; we all want to hear the sordid details of the lives of people who are clearly crazier than ourselves. Reality TV, "talk" shows, the 2 million incarnations of Judge Judy-type dramas; our entertainment so often revolves around the judgments we pass on other people.
What would life be like if we just lived in a world where dirty little secrets weren't so dirty? What if politicians and athletes and other public figures were not only encouraged, but embraced, by not the perception of living a "dirty little secret"-free life (which, let's face it, is an elaborate lie for almost all of us) but by their straightforwardness and honesty? What if nobody really cared what drugs Mrs. Smith had in her secret stash, or that Mr. Jones cheated on his wife, or that the head of the PTA had a criminal record? What if nobody was shocked, or entertained, or even interested in learning that other people, even famous, wealthy, accomplished people, had skeletons in their closets fairly similar to the ones most of us have?
Sure, everyone has different secrets, but almost all of us have them. Wouldn't it be a different kind of world if we were not so routinely fascinated by the secrets of others, by judging a person based upon one action or set of choices in his life? (really? Does Tiger Woods suddenly suck at golf because he likes to sleep with white girls he's not married to? If not, why do we care? His job is to be good at golf.) What if we all were forced to become more open about ourselves, and consequently, more accepting of others?
Well, there'd be a lot less TV, and people who made their livings from merely being as scandalous as possible, or "asking the tough questions" to try to unearth scandal from other people's lives...perhaps destroying them in the process, but certainly gaining a lot of media attention...would have to find new jobs. People would get their news from other sources besides the National Enquirer and Perez Hilton, and political pundits would actually have to use their power of snarkiness to deal with the issues. We'd all have to save our shock and outrage and "Oh, my God, that person is such a bad person" for things that might really deserve it. Just turn on the 5 o'clock news and see how many rapes, murders, kidnappings, and the like are going on in your neighborhood, and see if you still maintain that John Edwards is the worst guy on the face of the planet. Trust me, he's not.
On top of that, we might start being real about ourselves, and seeing that most of the secrets we keep aren't worth all the effort we go to in order to keep them. Why? To avoid public shame, or personal humiliation, or to avoid judgment by a group of people who almost all have secrets as shocking as yours? We might decide it's not worth putting someone down or ostracizing them because we've learned they like to have a drink at 3 PM, have a shoplifting habit, cheat on their spouse, dress in trashy lingerie, grow pot in their closet, or have a secret webcam site on the Internet.
I personally don't care if Bill Clinton inhaled, if Hillary is a lesbian, if Tiger can't keep it in his pants, if half of baseball's Hall Of Fame was on steroids, if my local politician likes to pick up strangers in airport bathrooms or S & M clubs, if Angelina is a crazy homewrecker, if Britney is bipolar, or if half of the contestants on my favourite reality show have rap sheets and naked photos out there. I don't care because I don't know these people, and also because I think there are better ways to make judgments on others than looking at how much "scandal" lurks in their lives. I'm not saying I'm perfectly open-minded, that I never judge, but in the grand scheme of things...who really gives a crap?
The world just might be a better place if we all realised how much energy we put into condemning other people, and how that could be re-directed and used positively.
I'd vote for a guy with three wives. I wouldn't vote for the guy who was told to be so ashamed of his three wives that he had to put so much time and energy into hiding and denying some of the most important and meaningful aspects of his life. But, that's on our society. Society tells us it's OK to tolerate just about anything shocking or taboo or unconventional, as long as it's kept sufficiently hidden. Our society encourages us all to value the outward appearance kept up by the second guy, and not the candour of the first...and when the second guy's secrets are unearthed, he's often crucified by the media, and by the public.
When did our priorities get so amazingly screwed up?
2 comments | Leave a comment
